For Sale

11 Prospect Avenue Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

$2,595,000

Listed July 6, 2026, 73 days ago

Listing courtesy of Donna L. Walker, Douglas Elliman Real Estate MLS #KEY1022345

Photograph of 11 Prospect Avenue Photograph of 11 Prospect Avenue Photograph of 11 Prospect Avenue Photograph of 11 Prospect Avenue Photograph of 11 Prospect Avenue
All 25 photos
  • 4Bedrooms
  • 2.5Bathrooms
  • 1,994Square feet
  • $1,301Per square foot
  • 1890Year built

About this home

Shelter Island Heights Icon Gracefully positioned in the heart of Shelter Island Heights, this timeless residence has been thoughtfully renovated and restored to honor its original character while seamlessly incorporating today's modern comforts. Rich in architectural charm and classic detail, the home offers an elegant blend of historic beauty and refined living. A gracious, oversized covered porch welcomes you upon arrival, providing the perfect setting to relax and enjoy the property's elevated position and picturesque water views. Inside, a warm and inviting foyer opens to beautifully proportioned living spaces, where natural light, period details, and a sense of understated sophistication create an atmosphere of effortless elegance. Toward the rear of the home, a formal dining room and well-appointed kitchen serve as the heart of the residence. Expansive windows and French doors bathe the interiors in natural light while creating a seamless connection to the surrounding landscape and outdoor living spaces. The second level is highlighted by a spacious primary suite featuring a generously sized bath, accompanied by two well-appointed guest bedrooms designed for comfort and privacy. The third floor offers a versatile retreat, ideal as a media room, den, home office, or additional gathering space for family and guests. Outside, the beautifully landscaped grounds provide a private sanctuary framed by mature trees and established plantings, creating a tranquil setting for relaxation and entertaining alike. Ideally situated just moments from the coveted Shelter Island Heights Beach Club, tennis courts, golf, marinas, shops, and beloved local restaurants, this exceptional offering presents a rare opportunity to own a meticulously restored home in one of Shelter Island's most desirable and historic neighborhoods.

Description supplied by the listing broker.

Features

  • Breakfast Bar
  • Entrance Foyer
  • Formal Dining
  • High Ceilings
  • Kitchen Island
  • Washer/Dryer Hookup

Property details

Interior

Flooring
Hardwood
Levels
Three Or More
Fireplace
Yes
Fireplaces
2
Appliances
Cooktop, Dishwasher, Dryer, Oven, Refrigerator, Washer

Systems and utilities

Heating
Propane
Cooling
Central Air
Utilities
Sewer Connected, Water Connected
Water
Public

Exterior and lot

Construction
Clapboard
Architectural style
Victorian
Parking
Garage

Community and fees

Association fee includes
Sewer, Water

Tax and legal

Parcel number
0700-006-00-02-00-002-000
Listing agreement
Exclusive Right To Sell

Property details supplied by the listing broker through OneKey MLS, as of September 18, 2026. Fields not shown were not supplied and should not be read as absent from the property.

This listing

  1. July 6, 2026 Listed at $2,595,000 73 days ago

Location

11 Prospect Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

Nearby homes for sale